Home Automobile How Ford's F-150 Lightning stacks up in opposition to Rivian and Hummer electrical pickups

How Ford's F-150 Lightning stacks up in opposition to Rivian and Hummer electrical pickups

How Ford's F-150 Lightning stacks up in opposition to Rivian and Hummer electrical pickups

SAN ANTONIO — Ford Motor’s new F-150 Lightning is an electrical pickup truck. That could seem apparent given it appears like a truck and has electrical motors and a battery pack as a substitute of an engine, but it surely must be stated.

Why? Because a profitable battery-powered pickup is a important step within the EV transition, for Ford and the business at giant.

While business chief Tesla has confirmed customers will buy electrical vehicles and Rivian Automotive has proven there’s demand for electrical life-style automobiles, the F-150 is essentially the most important take a look at to date as as to if EVs can transfer from compliance automobiles and area of interest vans to a product that may entice extra mainstream patrons.

The electrical pickup market, although nonetheless largely unproven, goes to be essential for traders to observe within the coming years. Trucks historically have fats revenue margins and account for about 20% of automobiles bought within the U.S., in keeping with auto intelligence agency Edmunds.

LMC Automotive expects the U.S. electrical pickup market to extend from about 25,000 automobiles this yr to 1 million or so by 2030. There are anticipated to be 5 electrical pickup fashions accessible in the marketplace this yr, and that is anticipated to leap to 21 over the subsequent decade.

Ford’s F-150 Lightning is the primary conventional pickup truck to go electrical. It’s not a GMC Hummer EV “supertruck.” It’s not a Tesla “Cybertruck.” It’s not a Rivian R1T “adventure vehicle.” It’s a pickup truck, electrified.

The advantages of the F-150 Lightning are much like the Hummer EV and Rivian R1T, however these electrical pickups — the one ones being bought presently within the U.S. — usually are not created equal. The three drive in a different way, and can enchantment to totally different patrons as soon as gross sales transfer previous early adopters into extra normal, EV-curious patrons.

F-150 Lightning

The Lightning lives as much as the F-150 identify in each operate and kind, performing as a bridge between the normal pickup folks know and a brand new EV. It shares a lot of its design and elements with its conventional sibling, except for the powertrains, some design tweaks and an non-compulsory 15.5-inch management display.

It’s additionally priced like a conventional pickup, starting from about $40,000 to greater than $90,000. That’s much like Ford’s present lineup of huge four-door pickups and in step with common costs of about $61,000 for a full-size pickup, in keeping with Cox Automotive.

An electrical pickup for the plenty is one thing Ford was in a singular place to deliver to market. Its F-Series lineup, together with the F-150, has been the best-selling car in America for 40 years and the highest truck for 45 years.

The firm got down to make an electrical model of the F-150 pickup truck, and it succeeded. The car operates as a full-size truck. But the electrification brings added advantages of basically instantaneous torque, elevated storage via a large entrance trunk, or “frunk,” the place an engine would historically be — and it removes the burden of getting to replenish on fuel.

The Lightning drives like an F-150 ought to, and that is not a foul factor. Ford and different automakers have more and more reworked pickups from harsh-riding work vans to comfy automobiles able to navigating easily on and off street.

The car’s giant battery gives for a good higher trip, because it retains the car extra grounded and gives a more in-depth 50-50 weight ratio for higher steadiness. On high of that, it gives a good towing expertise as a result of EVs do not require transmission gear adjustments, that are particularly noticeable when towing cargo.

While the Lightning is able to scaling hills or perhaps a little tough terrain, it does not match as much as the Hummer or R1T in that regard — however that is by design. This is a truck meant for mainstream patrons, not a distinct segment section. Ford sooner or later could supply such a hardier car, however this is not it.

The F-150 Lightning is able to as much as 580 horsepower and 775 foot-pounds of torque. Consumer fashions with its top-end 131-kWh battery begin at about $72,500 and have a variety of as much as 320 miles on a single cost. Its towing capability is as much as 10,000 kilos —between that of the Hummer and R1T. Vehicles with smaller batteries and a variety of 230 miles are cheaper but additionally supply much less efficiency.

Electric Ford F-150 Lightning

Andrew Evers / CNBC

One of the Lightning’s most original benefits over the Hummer and R1T is its capabilities for on-board energy technology. Ford loaded the car with shops and a bi-directional charging system that may energy a piece web site or a house within the occasion of a blackout for as much as 10 days, relying on power utilization.

Ford began transport the F-150 Lightning earlier this month for choose fleet patrons and greater than 200,000 reservation holders. The firm has not introduced when it can reopen its order financial institution, because it plans to ramp up manufacturing to 150,000 automobiles by mid-2023.


The Rivian R1T has a little bit of first-mover benefit within the electrical pickup market; manufacturing started final fall however is ramping up slowly. The R1T is succesful in each efficiency and off-roading, going 0-60 mph in about three seconds like a sports activities automotive, however it will possibly scale rocks or giant hills like a Jeep SUV.

Its inside and exterior styling, with vegan leather-based and actual wooden, are extra Tesla-like stylish than off-road brute. It’s additionally a a lot smaller car — about 16 inches shorter, the truth is — than the F-150 Lightning, making it extra similar to a Ford Ranger or Jeep Gladiator.

That speaks to how Rivian is positioning its merchandise as “adventure vehicles.” It’s how Jeep has described its SUVs for years, making Rivian extra of a menace to the Stellantis SUV model than the F-150.

For now, Rivian CEO RJ Scaringe agrees, telling CNBC throughout a current interview that the three pickups are every “pretty different products.” Cross-shopping between the Rivian R1T, the Hummer and the F-150, he stated, are extraordinarily low: “Clearly the objective and goals are different.”

Edmunds reviews consumers wanting on the R1T most frequently comparability store the Ford Mustang Mach-E crossover and different EVs, moderately than different pickups.

However, Scaringe has alluded to plans for a full lineup of automobiles at Rivian, which theoretically may embrace a bigger truck.

Rivian R1T electrical pickup truck

Source: Rivian

Starting pricing for the R1T ranges from $67,500 to $85,000. Vehicles presently accessible have as much as 314 miles of vary on a single cost with a 128.9-kWh “large” battery. Performance variations with 4 motors mix to supply 835 horsepower and 908 foot-pounds of torque. The car can tow as much as 11,000 kilos — an essential metric for a lot of pickup homeowners.


There’s a cause GM resurrected Hummer, a model infamously well-liked within the Nineties and 2000s for its extreme, gas-guzzling automobiles. Whether you really liked Hummers or hated them, you knew them. That means GM had model consciousness baked in so long as the brand new EV stayed true to kind for the model, and it does.

The Hummer EV pickup appears like a modernized model of its descendants. It’s giant, flamboyant and very succesful.

Instead of guzzling fuel, it drains plenty of power. The electrical Hummer is reportedly the least environment friendly electrical truck of the three at 47 MPGe, an electrical car vary equal for miles per gallon. That compares to 70 MPGe for each the R1T and F-150 Lightning. But once more, it is Hummer, so what did you anticipate?

The Hummer’s off-road functionality additionally stands out in contrast with the opposite two pickups, which helps clarify its decrease effectivity and greater than 9,000-pound weight.

This Hummer can scale rock climbs with ease, whereas additionally proving a easy on-road expertise and distinctive hands-free freeway driving with GM’s Super Cruise system. It additionally options elimination roof panels that may match into the car’s frunk and plenty of different particular and hidden options, together with a “crab walk” mode and quicker charging than the opposite vans.

GM threw the whole lot it had and extra into the Hummer when it comes to off-road and efficiency elements. Its $110,000 beginning worth is a testomony to that, forward of lower-priced variants anticipated within the years forward that would begin at $79,995.

GMC Hummer EV Edition 1

Michael Wayland / CNBC

The present top-end Hummer, regardless of its weight, can obtain 0-60 mph in about three seconds with its “Watts to Freedom,” or “WTF” mode. It’s able to as much as 1,000 horsepower and 1,200 foot-pounds of motor torque. Its vary on a single cost is as much as 329 miles with a 212.7-kWh battery pack (of which 205 is usable, GM says). It can tow as much as 7,500 kilos, the bottom raise of the three electrical pickups.

Unlike with the Rivian pickup, Edmunds reviews some notable cross-shopping between the electrical Hummer and its much less rugged rivals. Buyers within the Hummer have a look at the R1T and the Lightning for comparability greater than another fashions.

That crossover, although, nonetheless solely represents about 9% of these truck seekers.



Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here